4 railroads have requested federal appeals courts to throw out a new rule that might require two-person prepare crews in most circumstances, saying the mandate is unfair, capricious and an unlawful abuse of discretion.
The equivalent challenges of the Federal Railroad Administration’s rule have been all filed this week in several appellate courts on behalf of Union Pacific, BNSF and two quick line railroads — the Indiana Railroad and Florida East Coast Railway.
The brand new federal requirement, introduced final week, was a milestone in organized labor’s lengthy combat to protect the follow and got here amid growing scrutiny into railroad security, particularly within the wake of the fiery February 2023 derailment in jap Ohio.
Most of these railroads didn’t instantly supply further clarification for why they don’t just like the rule, however the business has lengthy opposed such a regulation and the Affiliation of American Railroads commerce group stated final week that the rule was unfounded and never supported by security information. The Indiana Railroad — like many quick strains throughout the nation — already operates with one-person crews, however the main freight railroads all have two-person crews that their union contracts require.
Union Pacific stated in a press release that “this rule, which lacks any information exhibiting two individuals in a cab are safer than one, hinders our capability to compete in a world the place expertise is altering the transportation business and prevents us from making ready our workforce for jobs of the long run.”
WATCH: Buttigieg on why rail security measures have stalled one yr after East Palestine catastrophe
BNSF deferred remark to AAR, and the 2 smaller railroads didn’t instantly reply to messages Thursday morning.
The regulators who introduced the rule final Tuesday and the unions which have lobbied for the coverage for years all argue there are clear security advantages to having two individuals within the cab of locomotives to assist function the prepare as a result of they’ll preserve one another alert and the conductor can reply instantly to any issues they encounter, together with serving because the preliminary first-responder to a derailment.
Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg has stated the necessity to enhance railroad security was made obviously clear final yr when a Norfolk Southern prepare derailed on the outskirts of a city on the Ohio-Pennsylvania border and spilled an assortment of hazardous chemical compounds that caught hearth. That East Palestine derailment impressed requires reform which have stalled in Congress.
However Buttigieg and the Federal Railroad Administration declined to remark Thursday on the authorized challenges to the brand new rule that’s set to take impact in early June.
Railroads have lengthy argued that the scale of prepare crews ought to be decided by contract talks, not regulators or lawmakers, as a result of they keep there isn’t sufficient information to indicate that two-person crews are safer. Present security stats can’t present how secure one-person crews are as a result of all the most important railroads have two-person crews now.
The brand new rule does embrace an exception that might enable quick line railroads to proceed working with one-person crews if they’ve been doing it for greater than two years and have a plan to make sure security. However the rule would make it troublesome for any railroads to chop their crews down to 1 individual.
The railroads have usually challenged states after they tried to require two-person crews, so it’s not a shock that they went to courtroom over this new federal rule.
The key freight railroads have argued that computerized braking techniques which are designed to forestall collisions have made the second individual within the locomotive cab pointless, and so they imagine a conductor primarily based in a truck might adequately reply to any prepare issues. Plus, they are saying taking that conductor off of the prepare would enhance their high quality of life as a result of she or he would now not should work unpredictable hours on the street.